History of Islam
(Up to the Demise of the Prophet)
Mahdi Pishva'i
Translated by: Dr. Mahmoud Farrokhpey
Footnotes 2
[1] Tarikh
al-tabari 2:191; Ibn al-Athir, Usd al-Ghabah 1:13; tabarsi,
I`lam al-Wara, pp. 5-6.
[2] Ibn
al-Athir, op cit, pp. 13; al-Bayhaqi, Dala'il al-Nubuwwah, pp.
118; Mas`udi, al-Tanbih wa’l-Ishraf, pp. 195-196; Ibn al-Athir,
al-Kamil fi’l-Tarikh 2:33; Ibn `Anbah, `Umdat al-talib,
pp. 28.
[3] Ibn Sa`d,
al-tabaqat al-Kubra 1:56; Al-Kalbi, Jamharat al-Nasab, pp.
17.
[4] Ibn
Shahrashub, Manaqib 1:155; tabarsi, op cit, pp. 6; al-Majlisi,
Bihar al-Anwar 15:105.
[5] Ibn
Shahrashub, op cit, pp. 155; Ibn `Anbah, op cit, p28.
[6] Ibn
Shahrashub, op cit, pp. 154; Ibn `Anbah, op cit, pp. 26; tabarsi, op
cit, pp. 6; Ibn Qutaybah, al-Ma`arif, pp. 67; tabarsi, Majma`
al-Bayan 10:546; Ibn Husham, al-Sirah al-Nabawiyyah 1:96; Ibn
`Abd-Rabbih, al-`Iqd al-Farid 3:312; Ibn Kathir, al-Sirah
al-Nabawiyyah 1:84; Muhammad Amin al-Baghdadi, Saba’ik al-Dhahab,
pp. 62, Ibn Wazih, Tarikh al-Ya`qubi 1:204.
Some genealogists have considered the
children of Fihr ibn Malik ibn Nizar as part of Quraysh. See Kalbi, op
cit, pp. 21; Ibn Sa`d, op cit, p55; Ibn Anbah, op cit, pp. 26; Ibn
Husham, op cit, pp. 96; Muhammad Amin al-Baghdadi, op cit, pp. 62; Ibn
Wazih, op cit, pp. 204; Ibn Hazm, Jamharat Ansab al-`Arab, pp.
12; Halabi, al-Sirah al-Halabiyyah 1:25-26.
There are some other statements
regarding this issue. See al-Sirah al-Halabiyyah 1:27.
[7] The Arab
groups and tribes are given different names, such as sha`b,
qabilah, `imarah, batn, fadkhdh and fasilah
in accordance with their extension and size. For instance, Khuzaymah was
a sha`b; Kinanah qabilah, Quraysh `imarah, Qusay
batn, Hashim fakhdh, and `Abbas fasilah. See
Ibn `Abd-Rabbih, al-`Iqd al-Farid 3:330; Husayn Mu'nis, the
History of Quraysh.
On the basis of this typology, some
researchers have attributed Quraysh to qabilah and some to
`imarah. But the very nature of this typology is a suspect; some
researchers would not accept it as such. See The History of Quraysh,
pp. 215-216. Here, we will refer to Quraysh as a qabilah (tribe).
[8] Mas`udi
states that the tribe of Quraysh had twenty-five branches and he
mentions them by names. See Muruj al-Dhahab 2:269.
[9] Halabi, op
cit, pp. 6.
[10] op cit, p6;
Shukri al-alusi; Bulugh al-Irab 1:324.
[11] Halabi, op
cit, pp. 6, al-alusi, op cit, pp. 323; Ibn al-Athir, al-Kamil fi’l-Tarikh
2:15, al-Buladhari, Ansab al-Ashraf 1:73.
[12] Halabi, op
cit, pp. 7; Mas`udi, Muruj al-Dhahab 2:109.
[13] al-alusi,
op cit, pp. 324, Ibn Wazih, Tarikh al-Ya`qubi 2:7; al-Sirah
al-Halabiyyah 1:7; Shaykh al-saduq, al-Khisal 2:312-313.
[14] saduq,
al-I`tiqadat, pp. 135; al-Majlisi, Bihar al-Anwar 15:117;
Usul al-Kafi 1:445.
Among the issues concerning `Abd
al-Muttalib is his vow to sacrifice one of his children for God. The
report on this vow, despite its fame, suffers some documental
considerations and needs further clarifications. See `Ali Dawani, The
History Of Islam From The Start To Hegira, pp. 54-59; Shaykh
al-saduq, Man-La-Yahzuruhu’l-Faqih 3:89.
[15] saduq, op
cit, pp. 135; al-Majlisi, op cit, pp. 117; Mufid, Awa’il al-Maqalat,
pp. 12; tabarsi, Majma` al-Bayan 4:322.
Some researchers have interpreted this
narration in the form of the cleanliness of the progenitor. See Sayyid
Hashim Rasuli Mahallati, Some Lectures On The Analytic History Of
Islam 1:64.
[16] Mufid, op
cit, saduq, op cit.
Some Sunni distinguished scholars,
such as al-Fakhr al-Razi and al-Suyuti, believe the same thing in this
regard as the Twelver Shi`ah. See Bihar al-Anwar 15:118-122.
[17] saduq,
Kamal al-Din, pp. 175; al-Ghadir 7:387.
[18] For further
information regarding these events, see Mas`udi, al-Tanbih
wa’l-Ishraf, pp. 172-181; Muhammad Ibrahim ayati, The History Of
The Prophet Of Islam, pp. 26-27.
[19] Mas`udi, op
cit, pp. 27.
[20] Shaykh
al-tusi, al-Amali, pp. 80-82; al-Bayhaqi, op cit, pp. 94-97; Ibn
Husham, op cit, pp. 44-55; al-Buladhari, op cit, pp. 67-69; Muhammad Ibn
Habib, al-Munammaq, pp. 70-77.
[21] Prior to
the event of the Elephant Army, Quraysh had appointed the death of Qusay
as a historical point of reference. See Tarikh al-Ya`qubi 2:4.
[22] Shaykh
al-Kulayni, Usul al-Kafi 1:439; Ibn Wazih, Tarikh al-Ya`qubi
2:4; Mas`udi, Muruj al-Dhahab 2:274; al-Majlisi, Bihar
al-Anwar 15:250-252; Halabi, op cit, pp. 95; al-Bayhaqi, op cit, pp.
72-73; Ibn Kathir, al-Sirah al-Nabawiyyah 1:201; Ibn Sa`d,
al-tabaqat al-Kubra 1:101; Ibn al-Athir, Usd al-Ghabah 1:14;
Ibn Husham, al-Sirah al-Nubawiyyah 1:167; `Abd al-Qadir Badran,
The Clarification Of The History Of Damascus; Ibn Ishaq,
al-Siyar wal-Maghazi, pp. 61.
[23] `Ali Akbar
Fayyaz, the History of Islam, pp. 62; `Abbas Ziryab, Sirat
Rasulillah, pp. 86-87; Sayyid Ja`far Shahidi, Tarikh Tahlili
Islam ta Payan Umawiyyan, pp. 37.
Concerning the exact date of the Holy
Prophet's birthday, whether it occurred in the Elephant Year or prior or
after it, the matter is not clear. For Further information, see
Muhammad The Last Of The Prophets 1:176-177; the article of Sayyid
Ja`far Shahidi in Rasuli Mahallati’s Lessons from the Analytical
History of Islam 1:107; Ibn Kathir, al-Sirah al-Nabawiyyah
1:203; Tahdhib Tarikh Dimashq 1:281-282; Sayyid Hasan Taqizadah,
From Parviz to Genghis, pp. 153; Husayn Mu’nis, the History of
Quraysh, pp. 153-159.
Furthermore, some European historians
explained the motive behind Abraha's military campaign to be an ambition
for territorial expansion against Iran via the northern part of Arabia,
which took place due to the Roman instigations. In Muslim reference
books, the motive is said to be religious due to the competition between
the Church in Yemen and the Kaaba in Hijaz. See Fayyaz, op cit, pp. 62;
Abu’-l-Qasim Payandeh, introduction of the translation of Qur’an into
Persian.
[24] Shaykh
al-Kulayni, op cit, pp. 439; Ibn Wazih, op cit, pp. 6. al-Karajaki,
Kanz al-Fawa'id 2:167.
The age of the Holy Prophet at his
father's death is also recorded as eleven months and twenty-eight days.
See Ibn Sa`d, al-tabaqat al-Kubra 1:100.
[25] Tahdhib
Tarikh Dimashq 17:282; Ibn Sa`d, op cit, 1:99; Mas`udi, al-Tanbih
wa’l-Ishraf, pp. 196; tabari, Tarikh al-Umam wa’l-Muluk
2:176; Ibn al-Athir, al-Kamil fi’l-Tarikh 2:10.
[26] Tarikh
al-Ya`qubi 2:6; Halabi, op cit, 1:143.
[27] Tarikh
al-Ya`qubi 2:6; I`lam al-Wara, pp. 6; al-Bayhaqi, op cit, pp.
110; Ibn al-Athir, Usd al-Ghabah 1:15; al-Majlisi, Bihar
al-Anwar 15:384.
[28] Halabi, op
cit, 1:146.
[29] Tarikh
al-Ya`qubi 2:7; Ibn Husham, op cit, 1:171; Ibn Sa`d, op cit, pp.
110; Mas`udi, al-Tanbih wa’l-Ishraf, pp. 196, Muruj al-Dhahab,
2:274; tabarsi, I`lam al-Wara, pp. 6; al-Bayhaqi, op cit, pp.
101-102; Ibn Kathir, al-Siyar wal-Maghazi, pp. 49.
[30]
Al-Buladhari, Ansab al-Ashraf 1:94; al-Maqdisi, al-Bad’
wal-Tarikh 4:131; al-Majlisi, Bihar al-Anwar 15:401; Ibn
Sa`d, op cit, 1:112.
[31] Tarikh
al-Ya`qubi 2:7; Ibn Shahrashub, op cit, 1:33; al-Buladhari, op cit,
pp. 44; Mas`udi, Muruj al-Dhahab 2:275.
[32] Ibn
Abi’l-Hadid, Sharh Nahj al-Balaghah 13:203; al-Majlisi, op cit,
pp. 401.
[33] Ja`far
Subhani, Forugh Abadiyyat 1:159; Sayyid Ja`far Murtaza al-`amili,
al-sahih min Sirat al-Nabi al-A`zam 1:81.
[34] Ibn Husham,
al-Sirah al-Nabawiyyah, 1:176; Ibn Sa`d, op cit, pp. 113; Halabi,
op cit, pp. 146; Khargushi, Sharaf Al-Nabi, pp. 146.
It is said while the Holy Prophet was
living with Halimah al-Sa`diyyah in the desert when the case of opening
his chest took place. However, experts in the history of Islam regard
this as invented and false for many reason. See Sayyid Ja`far Murtaza
al-`amili, al-sahih min Sirat al-Nabi al-A`zam 1:82; Sayyid
Hashim Rasuli Mahallati, Lessons From The Analytical History Of Islam
1:189, 204; Sheikh Muhmud Abu-Rayyah, Azwa'un `Ala al-Sunnah
al-Muhammadiyyah 1:175-177.
[35] Ibn Husham,
op cit, 1:171-172; al-Buladhari, op cit, pp. 93, Ibn Sa`d, op cit, pp.
110-111.
[36] Ibn
Shahrashub, a distinguished narrator, has dealt with this issue but has
not dealt with the Holy Prophet’s orphanage. See al-Manaqib 1:33.
[37] Salma, the
mother of `Abd al-Muttalib was from Yathrib and from Banu’l-Najjar. See
al-Bayhaqi, op cit, 1:121.
[38] Ibn Ishaq,
op cit, p65; al-Buladhari, op cit, pp. 94 Ibn Sa`d, op cit, pp. 116; Ibn
Husham, op cit, pp. 177; al-Bayhaqi, op cit, p121; tabarsi, op cit, pp.
9; saduq, Kamal al-Din 1:172; Tarikh al-Ya`qubi 2:7; `Abd
al-Qadir Badran, Tahdhib Tarikh Dimashq 1:223.
[39] Halabi, op
cit, 1:172.
[40] Ibn Husham,
op cit, 1:178; saduq, op cit, pp. 171; al-Majlisi, op cit, pp. 406;
Tarikh al-Ya`qubi 2:9.
[41] Ibn Husham,
op cit, pp. 189; al-Majlisi, op cit, pp. 406; tabari, op cit, 2:194.
[42] Tarikh
al-Ya`qubi, pp. 1; Ibn Sa`d, op cit, 1:119; al-Majlisi, op cit, pp.
407; al-Suhayli, al-Rawz al-Anif 1:193.
[43] Tarikh
al-Ya`qubi 2:11; Jawad `Ali, al-Mufassal 4:82.
[44] Ibn
Abi’l-Hadid, Sharh Nahj al-Balaghah 15:219.
[45] Ibn Sa`d,
op cit, 1:119; Ibn Shahrashub, op cit, 1:36; al-Majlisi, op cit, pp.
407; `Abd al-Qadir Badran, Tahdhib Tarikh Dimashq 1:285.
[46] Tarikh
al-Ya`qubi 2:11; Ibn Abi’l-Hadid, op cit, 1:14; Usul al-Kafi
1:453.
[47] A village
in Hawran, a province of Damascus. See Yaqut al-Hamawi, Mu`jam
al-Buldan 1:441.
[48] This issue
is brought up by the following Muslim historians and narrators: Ibn
Husham, al-Sirah al-Nabawiyyah 1:191-193; tabari, Tarikh
al-Umam wa’l-Muluk 2:195; Sunan al-Tirmidhi 5:90, h. 2620;
Ibn Ishaq, al-Siyar wa’l-Maghazi, pp. 73; Ibn Sa`d, Al-tabaqat
al-Kubra 1:121; Mas`udi, Muruj al-Dhahab 2:286; saduq,
Kamal al-Din 1:182-186; al-Buladhari, Ansab al-Ashraf 1:96;
al-Bayhaqi, Dala'il al-Nubuwwah 1:195; tabarsi, I`lam al-Wara,
pp. 17-18; Ibn Shahrashub, Manaqib 1:15; `Abd al-Qadir Badran,
Tahdhib Tarikh Dimashq 1:270, 354; Ibn Kathir, Sirat al-Nabi
1:243-249, al-Bidayah wa’l-Nihayah 2:229-230; al-Sirah
al-Halabiyyah 1:141; al-Majlisi, Bihar al-Anwar 15:409.
[49] Qur’an
2:41, 42, 89, 146; 7:157; 6: 20; 61: 6.
[50] Ibn Husham,
op cit, 1:193; al-Bayhaqi, op cit, pp. 195; Sunan al-Tirmidhi
5:590; `Abd al-Qadir Badran, Tahdhib Tarikh Dimashq 1:278; Ibn
Kathir, al-Sirah al-Nabawiyyah 1:245; saih al-Bukhari
5:28.
[51] Tarikh
al-Ya`qubi 2:11; al-Buladhari, Ansab al-Ashraf 1:81; Usul
al-Kafi 1:447.
[52] Gustav Le
Bon, The Islamic And Arab Civilization, pp. 101, Ignáz Goldziher,
Doctrine and Law in Islam, pp. 25; Muhammad Ghazzali, Trial of
Goldziher the Zionist, pp. 47; Karl Brockleman, History of Muslim
Peoples, pp. 34; Treason in Historical Accounts 1:220-225
[53] Will
Durant, The Story of Civilization, pp. 207.
[54] Qur’an
4:47,51,171; 5:72-73; 9:630.
[55] Shaykh
`Abbas al-Qummi, Safinat al-Bihar 2:727; Ibn al-Athir,
al-Nihayah fi Gharib al-hadith wa’l-Athar 5:282.
[56] Murtaza
al-`amili, al-sahih mi Sirat al-Rasul al-A`zam, pp. 106.
[57] Halabi, op
cit, 2:332.
[58]
Muhammad, a prophet who should be re-evaluated, pp. 5. This book
includes weak points, errors and distortions which decrease the
scientific value of its content. The style of the translator, too, is
quite peculiar; see Nashr Danish Magazine, eighth year, Issue, 2,
pp. 52, Article: a phenomenon called Zabihollah Mansuri, written
by Karim Emami.
[59]
Muhammad, the last of the prophets 1:188, the article of Sayyid
Ja`far Shahidi. Some contemporary Iranian historians have raised some
doubts on the issue of the Holy Prophet’s visit to Bahira, such doubts
and disturbances should be taken care of. We shouldn’t that even if we
superficially believe that this visit has not taken place, nothing is
taken away from the grandeur of the Holy Prophet, because there were
numerous other predictions of the coming prophet beside Bahira. The
reason why we have brought up the claims of the Orientalists here is to
show that they have used this issue to make some distortions in the
history of Islam.
[60] One of the
events in which the Holy Prophet is said to have participated in while
he was young was the war of al-Fujjar. It is said that this war
had taken place prior to Hilf al-Fuzul when the Holy Prophet was
14-20 years old. However, since his participation in this war is
doubtful, we will not follow it up here. See al-sahih min Sirat
al-Nabi al-A`zam 1:95-97; Some analytical lessons of the history
of Islam 1:303-503.
[61]
Ibn Sa`d, al-tabaqat al-Kubra 1:128; Muhammad Ibn Habib,
al-Munammaq, pp. 52.
[62] Muhammad
Ibn Habib, op cit, pp. 52-53; Ibn Sa`d, op cit, pp. 128; Tarikh
al-Ya`qubi 2:13; Ibn Husham, al-Sirah al-Nabawiyyah 1:142;
al-Buladhari, Ansab al-Ashraf 2:12.
[63] Muhammad
Ibn Sa`d, op cit. It is recorded that the age of the Holy Prophet was
even older at this time. Tarikh al-Ya`qubi 2:13; al-Munammaq,
pp. 53; Ibn Abi’l-Hadid, Sharh Nahj al-Balaghah 15:225.
[64] Ibn Husham,
op cit, pp. 142; Tarikh al-Ya`qubi, op cit, pp. 13; al-Buladhari,
op cit, pp. 16; Muhammad Ibn Habib, op cit, pp. 188.
[65] Muhammad
Ibn Habib, op cit, pp. 54-55
[66]
al-Buladhari 2:13. The memory of this treaty was still fresh at the
start of Islam. For instance, during the reign of Mu`awiyah al-Walid ibn
`Utbah ibn Abi-Sufyan was the governor of Medina. He quarreled with Imam
al-Husayn on a financial issue about the grove of Dhu’l-Marwah. Imam
al-Husayn said, “Is al-Walid acting arrogantly against me because he has
ruling authority? I swear by Allah, if he does not give me my due, I
shall take my sword and stand in the Mosque of Allah calling by the name
of Hilf al-Fuzul.” When his word was conveyed to `Abdullah ibn
al-Zubayr, he cried out, “By Allah I swear, if al-Husayn calls by the
name of Hilf al-Fuzul, I shall certainly take my sword and
support him; and then, either he will be given his due or we die
altogether.” When al-Walid was informed of these situation, he had to
give al-Husayn his due until he pleased him. See Ibn Husham, op cit,
1:142; al-Buladhari, op cit, 2:14; Halabi, op cit, 1:215; Ibn
Abi’l-Hadid, op cit, 15:226; Ibn al-Athir, al-Kamil fi’l-Tarikh
2:42.
[67] Ibn Husham,
op cit, 1:199; Ibn Ishaq, al-Siyar wa’l-Maghazi, pp. 81. Sibt ibn
al-Jawzi, in Tadhkirat al-Khawass pp. 301, says “Khadijah used to
employ them in the form of limited partnership.” Ibn al-Athir, in Usd
al-Ghabah 1:16, says: “She used to employ either in the form of
limited partnership or on a wage-system.”
[68] Ibn Sa`d,
op cit, 1:129.
[69] There are
some pieces of evidence which show that the Holy Prophet’s job was in
the form of limited participation and not on the basis of wage-earning
system. See al-sahih min Sirat al-Nabi al-A`zam 1:112.
[70] Ibn Husham,
op cit, pp. 199; Ibn Ishaq, op cit, pp. 81.
[71] Ibn Sa`d,
op cit, pp. 130.
[72] Ibn Sa`d,
op cit, 130.
[73] Ibn Ishaq,
op cit, pp. 82; Ibn Sa`d, op cit, p131; Ibn al-Athir, al-Kamil
fi’l-Tarikh 2:39; Tarikh al-tabari 2:196; al-Bayhaqi,
Dala’il al-Nubuwwah 1:215; Ibn al-Athir, Usd al-Ghabah 5:435;
al-Dulabi, al-Dhurriyyah al-tahirah, pp. 45-46.
[74] Ibn Husham,
op cit, 1:200-201; Ibn Sa`d, op cit, 1:131; al-Bayhaqi, op cit, 1:215;
al-Dulabi, op cit, pp. 46; Ibn al-Athir, al-Kamil fi’l-Tarikh
2:39.
[75] Ibn
al-Athir, Usd al-Ghabah 5:434; Halabi, op cit, 1:224; `Asqalani,
al-Isabah fi Tamyiz al-sahabah 4:281; Ibn `Abd al-Barr,
al-Isi`ab 4:279.
[76] Halabi, op
cit, 1:224.
[77] Her
previous husbands were `Utayq ibn `a’idh and Abu-Halah Hind ibn Nabbash.
See Ibn al-Athir, Usd al-Ghabah 5:434; Ibn Hajar, op cit, pp.
281; Ibn `Abd al-Barr, op cit, pp. 280; Halabi, op cit, 1:229;
Khargushi, Sharaf Al-Nabi, pp. 201; `Abd al-Qadir Badran,
Tahdhib Tarikh Dimashq 1:302.
According to some documents, Lady
Khadijah had never married before the Holy Prophet who, accordingly, was
her first and last husband. Some contemporary experts emphasize this
point. Murtaza al-`amili, al-sahih min Sirat al-Nabi al-A`zam
1:121.
[78] Ibn Sa`d,
op cit, al-Bayhaqi, op cit, pp. 215; tabari, op cit, 2:197; Halabi, op
cit, Ibn al-Athir, op cit, Ibn al-Athir, al-Kamil fi’l-Tarikh
2:40.
[79] al-Majlisi,
Bihar al-Anwar 16:22.
[80] al-Majlisi,
op cit, pp. 20-21; Ibn Husham, op cit, 1:203; Ibn Shahrashub, Manaqib
1:41.
[81] al-Majlisi,
op cit, pp. 21-23.
[82] Ibn Ishaq,
op cit, pp. 82; al-Buladhari, Ansab al-Ashraf 1:98; Tarikh
al-Ya`qubi 2:16; Ibn al-Athir, al-Kamil fi’l-Tarikh
2:40; Dulabi; op cit, pp. 46; Halabi, op cit, pp. 227; al-Majlisi, op
cit, 16:19.
[83]
al-Buladhari, op cit, pp. 98; Ibn Sa`d, op cit, 1:132; tabari, op cit,
2:196: Halabi, op cit, pp. 228; Ibn `Abd al-Barr, al-Isi`ab
4:280; Ibn al-Athir, Usd al-Ghabah 5:435; al-Kamil fi’l-Tarikh
2:39.
Regarding Lady Khadijah’s age, there
are various statements and records. See Amir Muhanna al-Khayyami,
Zawjat al-Nabi wa-Awladuhu, pp. 53-54.
[84] Ibn Husham,
op cit, 1:201; Dulabi, op cit, pp. 49; al-Bayhaqi, op cit, 1:216;
Khargushi, op cit, pp. 201; `Abd al-Qadir Badran, Tahdhib Tarikh
Dimashq 1:302; Ibn al-Athir, Usd al-Ghabah 5:434.
[85] Ibn Sa`d,
op cit, 1:121; Ibn Husham, op cit, 1:210; al-Bayhaqi, op cit, 1:211;
al-Majlisi, op cit, 15:369.
[86] This stone,
being the most sacred component of the Kaaba, is introduced as a
heavenly stone which became a component of Kaaba by Prophet Abraham due
to God's command. See al-Majlisi, op cit, 12:84, 99; al-Azraqi,
Akhbar Makkah 1:62-63. Al-Hajar al-Aswad is a reddish-black, oval
piece of stone set in the eastern side of the Kaaba at a height of one
meter and a half from the ground. It is the center of circumambulation.
[87] Ibn Sa`d,
op cit, 1:145-146, Tarikh al-Ya`qubi 2:14-15; al-Majlisi, op cit,
15:337-338; al-Buladhari, op cit, 1:99-100; Mas`udi, Muruj al-Dhahab
2:271-272. Some historians have given other reasons for the
reconstruction of the Kaaba. However, every historian has referred to
the Holy Prophet’s Judgment. See Ibn Ishaq, al-Siyar wal-Maghazi,
pp. 103; Ibn Husham, op cit, 1:205; al-Bayhaqi, Dala'il al-Nubuwwah.
[88] Ibn Husham,
al-Sirah al-Nabawiyyah 1:262; tabari, Tarikh al-Umam
wa’l-Muluk 2:213; Ibn al-Athir, al-Kamil fi’l-Tarikh 2:58;
al-Buladhari, Ansab al-Ashraf 2:90; Ibn Abi’l-Hadid, Sharh
Nahj al-Balaghah 13:119, and 1:15.
[89] Ibn
Abi’l-Hadid, Sharh Nahj al-Balaghah 1:15; Ibn Shahrashub,
Manaqib, 2:180.
[90] Abu’l-Faraj
al-Isfahani, Maqatil al-talibiyyin, pp. 15.
[91] Ibn
Abi’l-Hadid, op cit, pp. 13, pp. 200.
[92] Shaykh
al-tusi, al-Amali, pp. 624.
[93] Al-Suyuti,
Tarikh al-Khulafa', pp. 170.
[94] Nahj
al-Balaghah, Sermon 192.
[ PREVIOUS ] [
INDEX ] [
NEXT ]
|