If we exclude some Shi`a fanatics who regard all "Ahl al-Sunnah wal
Jama`ah" to be Nasibis, the vast majority of their scholars in the past
and the present believe that their brethren "Ahl al-Sunnah wal Jama`ah"
are the victims of Umayyad intrigues and cunning. This is so because they
thought well of the "good predecessors," emulating them without researching
or verifying their conduct. The latter, hence, misled them from discerning
al-Sirat al-Mustaqeem (the Straight Path) and distanced them from al-Thaqalain,
i.e. the Book of Allah and the Purified Progeny that safeguard whoever
upholds them from misguidance and guarantee for him sure guidance.
For this reason, we find them defending themselves and informing others
about their beliefs, calling for justice and equity and for unity with
their brethren "Ahl al-Sunnah wal Jama`ah." Some Shi`a scholars even toured
various countries looking for means to establish Islamic organizations
and institutions to close the gap between the sects and to bring about
unity. Others went to al-Azhar al-Shareef, the lighthouse of knowledge
and scholarship for "Ahl al-Sunnah," and met with its scholars with whom
they debated in the best manner, trying to remove the grudges. One such
scholar was Imam Sharafid-Din Sadr ad-Din al-Musawi who met Imam Saleem
al-Din al-Bishri, and the outcome of that meeting and the correspondence
between both great men was the birth of the precious book titled Al-Muraja`at,
a book which has played a significant role in narrowing Muslims' ideological
differences. The efforts of those scholars were also crowned with success
in Egypt where Imam Mahmud Shaltut, the then grand mufti of Egypt,
issued his brave fatwa granting full legitimacy to adherence to
the Shi`a Ja`fari sect, a sect the fiqh (jurisprudence) of which
is now among the topics taught at al-Azhar al-Shareef.
Shi`as in general and Shi`a scholars in particular have been trying
their best to introduce the Imams of the Purified Ahl al-Bayt to others
and to acquaint them with the Ja`fari sect which represents Islam in all
what this word implies, writing volumes of books and articles, holding
sessions, especially after the victory of the Islamic revolution in Iran,
conducting numerous conferences in Tehran under the banner of the Islamic
unity and the bridging of the gap between the Islamic sects. All these
are sincere calls for the renunciation of enmity and animosity, and to
instill the spirit of Islamic brotherhood, so that Muslims may respect
one another.
In every year, "Mutamar al-Wahdah al-Islamiyya" (Islamic Unity Conference)
invites Shi`a and Sunni scholars and thinkers to live one week under the
shade of a sincere fraternity, to eat and drink together, to pray, supplicate,
and exchange views and ideas, to give and take.
Had the only achievement of these conferences been creating unity and
narrowing the gaps between Muslims so that they may know one another and
remove their grudges, their good would be great, and their benefit overwhelming.
They will, by the Will of Allah, the Lord of the Worlds, in the end bear
the anticipated fruits.
If you enter the house of any ordinary Shi`a family, let alone the houses
of their scholars and the educated among them, you will find in it a library
containing, besides Shi`a works, a large number of books written by "Ahl
al-Sunnah wal Jama`ah," contrary to the case with the latter who very seldom
keep a Shi`a book. They, therefore, remain ignorant about the facts relevant
to these Shi`as, not knowing anything but the lies written by the enemies
of Shi`as. Even any ordinary Shi`a individual is most often familiar with
the Islamic history in all its stages, and he may even celebrate some of
its occasions.
As for the Sunni scholar, you will find him very seldom expressing interest
in history which he regards among the tragedies he does not wish to dig
up in order to be familiar with them; rather, he is of the view that neglecting
them and not looking into them is a must because they will undermine the
good impression held about the "good predecessors." Since he has convinced,
or misled, himself of the "justice" of all the sahaba and their
integrity, he no longer accepts what history has recorded against them.
For this reason, you find him unable to withstand any constructive discussion
based on proof and argument. You will find him either running away from
such a research due to his prior knowledge that he will be defeated, or
he may overcome his feelings and emotions and force himself into researching;
it is then that he rebels against all his beliefs, embracing, in the end,
the faith of the Ahl al-Bayt of the Prophet.
Shi`as are, indeed, the adherents to the Prophetic Sunnah because their
first Imam after the Prophet is Ali ibn Abu Talib who lived and breathed
the Prophetic Sunnah. Look at him and see how he reacted when they came
to him seeking to swear the oath of allegiance to him as the new caliph
on the condition that he should rule according to the "sunnah" of the shaykhain
(the two shaykhs, namely Abu Bakr and Umar ibn al-Khattab), whereupon he
said, "I shall not rule except according to the Book of Allah and the Sunnah
of His Messenger." Ali had no need for the caliphate if it was at the expense
of the Prophetic Sunnah, for he is the one who had said, "Your caliphate
to me is like a goat's sneeze except when I uphold one of the commandments
of Allah." His son, Imam al-Husayn, has made his famous statement which
is still ringing in the ears of history: "If Muhammad's faith is to be
straightened only if I am killed, then O swords! Take me!"
For this reason, Shi`as look at their brethren from "Ahl al-Sunnah wal
Jama`ah" with eyes of love and affection, desiring nothing for them except
guidance and salvation. To them, the price of guidance is recorded by authentic
traditions better than this life and everything in it. The Messenger of
Allah has said to Imam Ali upon sending him to conquer Khaybar, "Fight
them till they testify that There is no god except Allah, and Muhammad
is the Messenger of Allah; so if they utter it, their lives and wealth
will be protected against your might, and Allah will judge them. If Allah
guides through you even one single person, it is better for you than everything
on which the sun shines (or better than all red camels)."[54]
Ali's main concern was, after all, to guide people and to bring them
back to the Book of Allah and the Sunnah of His Messenger. For this reason,
his Shi`as nowadays are mostly concerned about refuting all the charges
and lies piled up against them, and about introducing to their brethren
from "Ahl al-Sunnah wal Jama'ah" the truth about Ahl al-Bayt and, hence,
guide them to the Straight Path.
Surely in the tales there is a lesson for men of understanding. It
is not a narrative that could be forged but a verification of what is before
it and a distinct explanation of all things, and a guide and mercy to those
who believe. (Holy Qur'an, 12:111)
[54] Muslim, Sahih, Vol. 7,
p. 122 "Kitab al-Fadail" (Book of Virtues), the chapter dealing with the
merits of Ali ibn Abu Talib .