Islam, in being founded on such a worldview, is a
comprehensive and realistic teaching. It considers every aspect of human needs, whether
this worldly or otherworldly, physical or spiritual, intellectual or emotional and
affectual, individual or social. From one standpoint, the aggregate of Islamic teachings
comprises three areas:
1. Principles of belief, that is, things in which it is the duty of
every individual to strive to attain belief. The task that man is charged with in this
area falls under the heading of investigation and the acquisition of knowledge.
2. Morals, that is, traits that it is the duty of every Muslim to
incorporate and adorn himself with and whose opposites it is his duty to shun. The task
that man is charged with in this area falls under the heading of self-control and
self-moulding.
3. Decrees, that is, rules that relate to the overt and objective acts
of man, inclusive of acts with this worldly and otherworldly ends, and of individual and
social acts.
According to the Shi'i school of thought, the principles of Islamic
belief are five: Tauhid, justice, prophecy, the Imamate, and the Hereafter (ma'ad,
the Destination). As regards the principles of belief, according to which each
individual is charged with acquiring a right belief, Islam does not regard imitation and
blind submission as sufficient; every individual must freely and independently verify the
rightness of these beliefs. According to Islam, worship is not confined to physical acts
of worship, such as the alms-taxes zakat and khums. There is another kind of
worship, and that is mental worship. Mental worship, or contemplation, if directed at
man's admonition and awakening, is superior to years of physical worship.
Where Thought Stumbles
The Glorious Qur'an, in summoning us to reflect and draw conclusions,
in regarding reflection as worship, and in not regarding acceptance of the principles of
belief as sound without logical reflection, has attended to this basic question: Where do
the stumbling in human thought arise? What is the taproot of error and straying? If one
wishes to think straight and avoid error and deviation, what must one do?
In the Glorious Qur'an, a series of phenomena are named as the
occasions and causes of error and straying: reliance on supposition, psychical tendencies
and desires, haste, traditionalism, and obedience to personalities.
Reliance on Supposition Instead of Knowledge and Certainty
The Noble Qur'an, in numerous verses, stringently opposes action based on supposition
instead of knowledge and certainty; it says:
"Do not pursue that of which you have no knowledge" (17:36)
and "The nature of most people is such that if you try to follow them, they will
mislead you, because they rely on supposition (not on certainty) and act solely on
conjecture and estimation" (paraphrase of6:116). Modern philosophy has established
that this tendency is one of the chief factors in error and confusion.
A thousand years after the Qur'an, Descartes made this recognition the
first principle of his logic. He says: "The first of these [precepts to which I have
adhered] l was to accept nothing as true which I did not clearly recognise to be so: that
is to say, carefully to avoid precipitation and prejudice in judgements, and to accept in
them nothing more than what was presented to my mind so clearly and distinctly that I
could have no occasion to doubt it."
Psychical Tendencies and Desires
If one wishes to judge rightly, one must preserve a complete impartiality toward the
matter under consideration; that is, one must strive to find only reality and submit to
reasons and evidence. One must be just like a judge considering a case, impartial to the
two sides of the dispute. If a judge has a personal bias toward one side, he will
unconsciously pay more heed to the reasons adduced for that side's case. Such a bias will
cause the judge to err.
If in his own reflections one fails to preserve his impartiality
relative to the negation or affirmation of a matter, if his psychical tendencies are to
one side, automatically, without his being aware, the meter-needle of his thought will
swing to the side of his psychical tendencies and desires. Thus, the Qur'an terms the
desires of the psyche, along with reliance on supposition, one of the factors in thought's
stumbling. It says in the Sura Najm: "They follow nothing but supposition and
what their own psyches desire" (53:23).
Haste
Every judgement or expression of opinion demands a certain amount of evidence. Until
sufficient evidence has been gathered on a question, any son of expression of opinion
constitutes haste and occasions stumbling in thought. The Noble Qur'an repeatedly alludes
to the paucity of man's stock of knowledge and its insufficiency for some major
judgements; it conceives of dogmatic assertions as highly imprudent. For instance, it
says: "Only a little knowledge has been given you" (17:85), which is to say that
the amount of knowledge and information that has reached us is slight and insufficient for
judgement.
Imam Sadiq (peace be upon him) has said:
In two verses of the Qur'an God has singled out His servants and
admonished them: first, that they not affirm a thing until they have attained knowledge of
it [haste in affirmation], and second, that they not deny a thing until they have attained
to knowledge of it-until they have reached the stage of knowledge and certainty [haste in
denial]. God says in one verse: "Was not the Covenant of the Book [the book of
essential disposition or the revealed books] taken from them that they would not ascribe
to God anything but the truth?" (7:169). He said in the other verse: "But they
deny what their knowledge does not encompass' (10:39)
Traditionalism and Looking to the Past
In accordance with his first nature, when man sees that a particular thought or belief was
accepted by past generations, he automatically accepts it without allowing himself time to
consider it. The Qur'an reminds us not to accede to the accepted notions and beliefs of
past generations until we have weighed them on the scales of reason, and recommends
independence of thought vis-a-vis the beliefs of past generations.
It says in the Sura Baqara, verse 170:
"When it is said to them, 'Follow what God has sent down,' they
say, 'No, we follow the customs we found our ancestors to believe in.' What! Even though
their ancestors were void of reason and unguided?" (2:170).
Obedience to Personalities
Another of the occasions of stumbling in thought is obedience to personalities. Great
historical and contemporary personalities, owing to the proportions of grandeur they
assume in others' minds, exert an influence on others' thoughts and wills, to the point of
overwhelming them. Others think as they think and resolve as they resolve. Others give up
their independence of thought and will to them.
The Noble Qur'an summons us to independence of thought and regards blind following of
great men and personalities as leading to eternal torment. Accordingly, it has the
people who were lost down this road say on the resurrection: "Our Lord! We obeyed our
leaders and great men, and so they misled us as to the path" (33:67).